Saturday, October 4, 2008

திருடி எடுக்கப்பட்ட தமிழ் சினிமாக்கள்!

தொடர்ந்து என் எழுத்துக்களை உங்கள் விமர்சனத்திற்கு திங்க கொடுப்பதிலோ, அதற்க்கு பதில் சொல்லிக் கொண்டும் என் காலத்தை வீணடிக்க விரும்பாத காரணத்தால் இப் பகுதியை நீக்குகிறேன்.

23 comments:

Rajesh said...

சாட்டை அடி..

Joe said...

you will be able to write another, similar article even in 2108, nothing change here! LMAO

tamilraja said...

சில சரியாகவும்,சில தவறாகவும் உங்கள் எண்ணம் என்னும் போக்கில் பதிந்து இருக்கிறீர்கள்!

சரோஜாவின் மெயின் தீம் "மென் ஆன் பயர்"!

இதற்க்கு முன் இதே படம்
தமிழில்,ஆணை என்று வந்தது.
தெலுகில் அதிதி யாக வந்தது

போக்கிரி நிறைய தென்னிந்திய படங்களில் வந்த கதை

சில காட்சி அமைப்புகள் ஸ்டண்ட்மாஸ்டர்கள் ஆங்கிலப்படத்தை பார்த்து அமைப்பார்கள்.
அதை மொத்த படத்தின் தன்மை மேல் போடக்கூடாது
.
கிளாடியேட்டருக்கும்,ரமணாவுக்கும் என்ன சம்பந்தம் ??????

Praveen's Thoughts said...

pls answer......கிளாடியேட்டருக்கும்,ரமணாவுக்கும் என்ன சம்பந்தம் ??????

இவன் said...

சரியான அடி... Word Verification ஐத்தூக்கிவிடுங்களேன்

mrcritic said...

எந்த படத்தின் தாக்கமும் இல்லாமல் நீங்கள் எடுக்கப் போகும் படத்திற்கு வாழ்த்துக்கள்.

Thee said...

u r wrong in many examples. I won't accept the fact that city of God and Pudhupettai is same. If u think so, then if we take the issue of yopungsters in the violent path, u will point it out to City of God everytime. And Veyil, Autograph may have similarities with Cihema Paradiso. But definitely not same. Veyilodu vilayaadi song brings out the entire child hood games and life. Is it the same way in cinema Paradiso? Pothaam podhuvaa pesak kudadhu.

buginsoup said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ஸ்ரீ said...

உங்களின் எழுத்துக்கு பாராட்டு!
உங்கள் எழுது மனதில் பதிகிறது அழுத்தமாய்,
அனால் அதில் தோன்றுவது கோபம் மட்டுமே!!
அதில் சிந்தனை சிதறடிக்க அசை படுகிறேன்...

இது மொத்தமாய் உங்கள் எழுத்தை ரசித்து உண்டபின்
கூற நினைப்பது...

மதுவில் வீழ்ந்த காதல்!- நன்று

ஒரு கலைஞனுக்கு கோபம் தவறு,
பொது சிந்தனையில்....

narendran said...

nammudaya ennangal annaithum , eppothum nammai sutri iruppavargal matrum naam sinthipavargalai saarnthey amaiyum enbathu ennudaya ennam. appadi irukumaanal avrkaludaya sinthanaigal nammai aatuvippathil entha thavarum illai.
Neengal solvathu mattravarkaluku ketke vendum endral neengal ore uyarathil irunthu athai solla vendum. antha uyarathirku neengal nichayam varuveergal.

APPOTHU ungalai patri ithey pol veru oruvar eluthuvar. Ithai patri naam sinthipathai vida nam adutha illakai nokki naam payanam seiya vendum.
Ithu ennudaya karuthu,ennam.

Sathish Yadav said...

பெரு மகிழ்ச்சி நண்பா உண்மையின் வெளிப்பாட்டில் ஆக்ரோஷம் தெரிகிறது இதே தீர்கமான ஒரு கலைஞனின் அடையாளம்

இப்படி அடி மேல் அடி வைத்து நடந்தால் மட்டுமே தமிழ் திரையுலகில் சில மாற்றங்களையாவது நம் வாழ் நாளில் பார்க்க முடியும்.

தமிழனின் பெருமையை பணத்துக்காக மண்ணை கவ்வ வைத்துக் கொண்டிருக்கும் மாக்களுக்கு என்று தான் அறிவு பிறக்குமோ..

Mohamed said...

Good job on research however i'ld have appreciated you if you had taken some time to watch all the movies you have posted here.

Since i have seen some of the movies, here is my observation.

I don't see any similarity between AE & Ameros Perros in story, its only the screenplay pattern that has been inspired. In fact AE had a much better story and it had a gripping screenplay compared to AP. AE had a single story where three characters are part of it and drive the story, whereas in AP, there are 3 different & identical stories where the main characters from 3 stories meet at the same scene. Apart from the 1st story, the rest 2 would put you off.

Guys....pls watch AP & give your honest opinion.

I have seen Rashoman...which is a timeless classic made in 1950 however i don't want to comment, as i haven't seen Adhe Kanngal.

Coming to Pachai kili...The movie Derailed itself is inspired by the novel of the same name. Gautham has made it very clear that the story is based out of the novel and he scripted the movie before Derailed (movie) got released. Pachai Kili...was the initial story narrated to Kamal however since he rejected they went with ahead with VV. I don't want to comment on "Memories of murder" as i'm yet to watch it...thanks for bringing it up...i will def give it a shot.

You have mentioned about Pollathavan and "Bicycle Thief"...apart from the bicycle getting stolen and the hunt for it...the story and the screenplay are poles apart.

Umpteen number of times it has been discussed over the years that Nayagan has just used a thread from God Father....the screenplay was based on the real story of then Mumbai don Varatharajan. If your point is true why would they select Nayagan as one of the top 100 movies released worldwide this
century. To your knowledge GF is also part of it.

Only last week i had a glimpse at "The Untouchables" becoz i was curios to know whether Kakka Kakka is inspired from it as i read it on "The Hindu" couple of months back. To my surprise i don't see any similarities on both the movies. There is a couple of scenes, which had slight resemblance that too only to an extent.

I haven't seen "Mystic River" but when i read the story from Wikipedia.....i couldn't stop laughing from your ignorance.

I seriously couldn't believe how on earth you come to a conclusion that Nandalala & VA are copied from the movies you mentioned before they got released. Don't go by the rumors that appear in cinema magazines.

"Gladiator" is one of my fav period film...I haven't seen "Dhurai" (I think it is the recent Arjun movie which u r mentioning)but i've read the story...again where s the similarity?

I agree with you on certain movies like Gajini, Vegam, Anniyan, Mrs. Doubt fire, where the core story is inspired from the movies you have mentioned.

I am yet to watch other movies which you claim to be the main source of inspiration for movies like “Roja, Kandukondein, Kushi, JJ, Kadhalar Dhinam, Pokkiri, Namavar, Veyil, May Madham, Guna, Sathi Leelavathi, Pattiyal, Dham Dhoom, Ali Baba, Saroja …” so I reserve my comments later.

My sincere advice is for you to watch all the movies you have mentioned before posting a comment …don’t blindly go with what you read or what you heard.....better come to a conclusion after watching.

It is very obvious that you are frustrated in getting a break in filmdom which forced you to pull others through digital media….. It is easy to pin point your fingers at others….so let’s see what you are up to when you get your chance….my best wishes for your hunt.

Mohamed said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
deesuresh said...

தங்கள் ஆதங்கம் புரிகிறது. நமக்குக் காணக் கிடைக்கா அரிய படங்களை, நமக்காக, இந்த இயக்குநர்கள் அவர்கள் பாணியில் கொடுத்திருக்கிறார்கள் என்று வைத்துக் கொள்ளலாமே..!!

Arun Saravanan said...

this is the no.1 comedy blog i've ever seen in my life. i don't believe you are working as an assistant director. I have watched almost all the tamil and foreign movies you've mentioned which are copied/robbed. Don't mention anything without knowing. There is nothing related to the movies you've mentioned except anniyan, avvai shanmugi, derailed, etc.

Stupid. First watch those foreign language movies and then post anything.

Untouchables is a gangster movie - Kakka Kakka????

Amores Perros is movie abt unrelated three persons and their life meeting at a point - Aayutha Ezuthu is abt youth in Politics????

PachaiKili Muthu Charam - Based on Derailed Novel

Gladiator - Ramana, are u nuts???

Rashomon is abt rape and murder and witness prosecution - Athe Kangal????

Autograph got three heroins and love, Veyil is abt son runnning from home - What do u get from Cinema Paradiso to relate those. Damn, You r blind man.

City of God is abt young rogues, dope and weapon supply inside a city - Pudhupettai got any relation with that????

This clearly explains that you are a half boiled, never watched any of those foreign movies...

Mohamed said...

I agree with you Arun.....this guy hasn't seen any of those movies.... he just blindly posted his comments.

த.கிருஷ்ணமூர்த்தி said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Sam said...

U stupid.... "Derailed" movie is an adaptation of the novel "Derailed".

Don't think you are the encyclopedia of cinema !!! you dumb ***

natty said...

we have made a meipporul movie from one kural from thirukural. When the movie is out you can see the changes that is going to happen in tamil cinema

யாத்ரீகன் said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
krishna said...

Kamahasans Anbesivam--> Plane Tranis and Automobiles.

free beastiality stories said...

She imagined rubbing some cream on hischest, down his navel and then some more on his prickand then slowly lick it all off with very, very slowlicks. He screamed.
nifty gay stories
free adult child erotic stories
xnxx stories jacking off with dad
interracial wives stories
adult white wives cuckold stories
She imagined rubbing some cream on hischest, down his navel and then some more on his prickand then slowly lick it all off with very, very slowlicks. He screamed.

Katz said...

classic- sikku pukku